It will be understood in the course of time:Aşkın Nur Yengi, musicianI like his voice very much. And I think that his album will be understood in the course of time. A song will be meaningful if it matches with the story of a listener. And it takes time.He is a person who hides the exotic smell of the Mediterrian in his soul. It is not easy to meet with approval by such a legend as Ahmet Ertegün.
His credit cannot be failed:YaşarHe is the first and only star who passed beyond the borders of our Turkish music. He is the first Turkish pop icon who could sell his albums around the whole Europe and give concerts to a large audience. Also, he is the owner of all the records which had done in his area. Though his latest two albums were not as good as the other ones, after all these successes, his credit cannot be failed.
He is the fashion of the year:Erkan Ozarman, organizerI haven’t listened to his album yet but I have seen such men who are attcking him by saying “My album is better than his”. Look at the fashion magazines, he is the fashion of the year. And there is not a rule that everybody listens to every album. Moreover, all the lyrics and compositions belong to him. This is a courage. Congratulations. But I wish he had a much more professional team around him. I know his menager Uygar. He is smart and gentleman. But being a menager and being an organizer are different situations.
If Ortaç or Sandal did it, we would say that it was good:Naim Dilmener, music writerI don’t know how a personality he has and I don’t need to know. But as he is presented, he does everything perfect. He is like a brave rowdy boy. We are criticising this image, maybe some of doesn’t like it but he seems convincing in that suit and shirt, he may even have a gsm on his hand or a rosary. Don’t think that I’m against this album. If somebody did this album, we would say it was a good job. It is a well-organized album. And Ozan Çolakoğlu’s contribution is crucial. But if it is Tarkan, then we say “ No, Not Good.” It’s not just the high expectation of us. He always surpass himself with the other album. If Serdar Ortaç or Mustafa Sandal did this album, we would say that it was good. But Tarkan should have done something different in 2008.
The ones who don’t like it will be amused:Hakan Eren, supervisorAlthough he didn’t do a different album as it was expected, it is a nice one. Its sound is not new, but it matchs with Tarkan. He likes dilemma in lyrics, he has to change this style. He uses the way of choosing proverbs. He might have worked with Sezen Aksu, this would be better. If we think that hip-hop and R&B are popular throughout the world, that is normal to use this sounds with fiddle and tomtom since this album was mad efor Turkish people. I’m sure that once people appropriate these songs, they will have other versions. You will like his songs by listening to them over and over again. And we will see that the ones who don’t like his songs will be amused by them after some time.
Not Tarkan’s but pop music’s period has finished:Zeki Coşkun, journalist of RadikalMetamorphosis signs a transformation in both Tarkan’s and Turkish pop music’s history. There is no new or special event. Also, it is not right to mention about a downfall. Tarkan is the same Tarkan, music is the same music. Everything as usual as it was like he said in his first song Hop Hop: “ Always the same story/ Everything is the same”. What were people expecting so much that now they are talking about a disappointment? Answer: The problem is that pop music’s period has finished.
I wish he sang classic Turkish musicFikret Şenes, lyric writerHis voice is great. But how can a song be as “Babbler”? I don’t like the name of the album. Metamorphosis. It recalls the tail of a lizard. Actually, once I didn’t like the name of the song “ Don’t Forget”(Unutmamalı), since such suffixes in Turkish does not sound good. I wish he song in classic Turkish music.
Metrosexual image leaves its place to strong man image:Deniz Durukan, lyric writerMetamorphosis symbols transformation and the wish for a change. Years ago, Tarkan appeared as a unisex image. The sensitive and metrosexual men image in the middle of the 90s left its place to a much more strong and bossy image. Men wants to regain their old image which belongs to them. Of course, this change is related to the period’s political view. Every period creates its own politic star. Tarkan is a clever man. He realizes the demand of this period. All in all, he is always successful to make people talk about himself. Yesterday, while we were talking about metrosexual men, today we are making comments on the chancing the profile of men over the image of Tarkan.
They will lay out Tarkan:Fikri Nazif Ayyıldız, the old publishing director of Nokta MagazineTarkan broke a taboo! He used his body as show material like his colleagues in America and Europe. Moreover, he did it in such a sytlish and aesthetic way. After climbing up the stairs of fame, he learned to look at in a meaningful way which confused women’s mind. In his concerts, there were hysteris crisised among women. So we put him on our cover since he became a phenomenon because of having a successful psychological bond with all the people. 13 years passed but Tarkan is stil very handsome, dynamic and he is stil searching for himself. But the country which he came in 90s is not the same country now. City dwellers are going away. Villagers invaded to the city and they gradually exuded to the life of city dwellers. They began to make their own music with a language we had difficulty to understand. Among these styles, Tarkan seems weird. He seems to me like an old and sad image.
If being abroad means to be far away from your homeland, then Tarkan is not an expatriate from the beginning of his life. Though he is a child of a family who migrates from Rize to Germany, he opens his eyes to life in a town called Alzey which is located to Frankfurt. The country which is a foreign land for his family means his birth place for Tarkan. Although it is located to an European city, Tarkan’s birth place is just a town and like every artist, he has a fragile heart which carries the feeling of homesick. That’s why maybe he writes these lyrics in the song Ragged (Pare Pare): “ I met with the game of destiny very early, I grew up suddenly/ Now my childhood days are lost.” Actually these sentences tell us a lot of things!
He is the fifth of six children. It is his luck that his family is not conservative. His family could orientate themselves in Germay. He studied in German schools till he was 14 years old. He was growing up by acquiring these two cultures. In his teenage years, he listened to Ibrahim Tatlıses. Dom Dom Kurşunu was the first song folk song he listened to. And after that he began to listen to Zeki Müren. Lastly, he met with the songs of Sezen Aksu who would be his queen. Moreover, we should add to this music list the punk music which was effective during the 80s. In order to understand the “music world” of Tarkan, you should look at this list. Before remembering the first stage performance on the New Year of 1992, you should look at these mixed cultural effects upon his music.